Cognitive Training fMRI (ds002843)
Cognitive Training
Brain MRI and task fMRI of healthy young adults before and after 10 weeks of commercial cognitive training or video games, from a randomized trial of whether training changes brain activity during delay discounting and risky choice.
Overview
This release holds the imaging data of a randomized controlled trial at the University of Pennsylvania (Joseph Kable and Caryn Lerman) that asked whether commercial adaptive brain training changes decision making. Healthy young adults were scanned before and after 10 weeks of home training with either Lumosity or non-adaptive online video games. In the scanner they made choices between immediate and delayed rewards and between certain and risky rewards. The trial found no training effect on brain activity, choice behavior or cognitive tests beyond the trained games. The data sit on OpenNeuro as ds002843 in BIDS under CC0.
Composition
166 participants aged 18 to 34 were randomized, 84 to cognitive training and 82 to the video game control. Every participant has a baseline session, and 127 have a second session after training. participants.tsv labels 64 participants per arm as trained or control and marks the other 38 as not having finished both sessions. It also gives sex, age, education and the Shipley intelligence score. 98 participants are male and 68 female.
Acquisition
All scans were done on one Siemens Trio 3 T with a 32-channel head coil. Each session has an MPRAGE T1-weighted image, a T2-weighted spin echo image, field maps, a resting-state run and up to four runs each of the delay discounting and the risky choice tasks. The task runs are EPI with 3 mm voxels and a repetition time of 3 s, and trial-level events with the choices are included. A diffusion-weighted scan exists in 262 of the 293 sessions.
Annotations
There are no image labels. Events files give the offers and the accept or reject response for every task trial.
Known limitations
- The paper analyses 128 completers and 114 after fMRI quality exclusions; the release keeps all 166 randomized participants, including those lost to follow-up.
- One participant in the training arm has only the baseline session.
- Eligibility excluded people with extreme baseline discounting or risk preferences, IQ below 90 and MRI contraindications, so the sample is narrow.
- The T2-weighted and diffusion scans are not described in the paper; their parameters come only from the BIDS sidecar files.
Cohort
Aggregate numbers from the sources below. Bars are relative to the 166 subjects.
Sex
- Female 68 41%
- Male 98 59%
sex in participants.tsv of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), counted per row
Contrast / sequence
Groups can overlap
- T1-weighted 166 100%
- T2-weighted 166 100%
- BOLD fMRI 166 100%
- Diffusion-weighted 153 92%
anat/*_T1w.nii.gz, anat/*_T2w.nii.gz, func/*_bold.nii.gz, dwi/*_dwi.nii.gz in File tree of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), NIfTI files counted per subject, session and BIDS suffix
Scanner vendor
- Siemens Healthineers 166 100%
Materials and Methods: Neuroimaging and primary outcomes in Kable et al. 2017, No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance, Journal of Neuroscience (PMC full text)
Country
- United States 166 100%
Materials and Methods in Kable et al. 2017, No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance, Journal of Neuroscience (PMC full text)
Age
mean 24.5, median 24, range 18 to 34
age in participants.tsv of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), counted per row
Condition
Groups can overlap
- Healthy control 166 100%
Materials and Methods: Participants and eligibility in Kable et al. 2017, No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance, Journal of Neuroscience (PMC full text)
Field strength
- 3 T 166 100%
Materials and Methods: Neuroimaging and primary outcomes in Kable et al. 2017, No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance, Journal of Neuroscience (PMC full text)
Age by sex
Reported cross table. Missing cells were not published (fewer than 10 or not reported).
- n/a30-3915
- 4720-2967
- 1210-1916
sex and age in participants.tsv of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), counted per row
Contrast combinations
How many subjects have exactly each set of contrasts.
| T1w | T2w | dwi | bold | Subjects with exactly this set |
|---|---|---|---|---|
153 | ||||
13 |
From File tree of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), NIfTI files counted per subject, session and BIDS suffix
License and access
Our reading of the license, not legal advice. Before you use the data, read the original license and confirm that your use is allowed. We take no responsibility for how you use a dataset. Full disclaimer
Download without an account
Creative Commons Zero 1.0 Universal
Public domain dedication. Do anything with the data, including commercial use, without asking and without having to give credit.
dataset_description.json of snapshot 1.0.1 states "License" CC0.
What you can do
- Yes
- Yes
- Yes
- Yes
- Yes
What you can share
- Yes
- Yes
- Yes
What you must do
- No
- Share alike No
- No
- No
- Manuscript review No
- Release code No
- Return results No
- Delete after use No
Limits
- No
- Location limits No
Citation
Kable JW, Caulfield MK, Falcone M, et al. No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance. Journal of Neuroscience 37(31), 7390-7402 (2017). doi:10.1523/JNEUROSCI.2832-16.2017
Sources
Every number on this page comes from one of these documents. Each chart names the table or page it is taken from. The raw numbers are in stats.csv.
- Kable et al. 2017, No effect of commercial cognitive training on brain activity, choice behavior, or cognitive performance, Journal of Neuroscience (PMC full text) paper
- OpenNeuro ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (dataset_description.json, README, CHANGES and snapshot summary) website
- participants.tsv of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), counted per row computed
- File tree of ds002843 snapshot 1.0.1 (CC0), NIfTI files counted per subject, session and BIDS suffix computed